It may be purely down to the jet size. If too much acetylene is coming out, it won't burn very efficiently.
What a good lamp will do is burn bright yellow with minimum soot. Too much gas/not enough air will produce soot. The bright yellow of a flame is incandescent carbon particles - same for a paraffin lamp, candle, or gas lamp. Optimum efficiency for a flame producing light is where there is enough carbon in the flame to glow brightly, but the carbon is largely oxidised to carbon dioxide, hence little soot. A smoky flame shows there is too much acetylene being supplied for the amount or air available, so it produces light and soot. The oxy-acetylene cutting torch provides so much oxygen that all the energy produced provides heat, not light, and no soot. When the oxygen supply to a cutting torch is turned off, the flame immediately turns yellow and smokey.
So to reduce soot in a lamp, perhaps a narrower jet is required, or perhaps these lamps were smokey and this was accepted by those that used them.