A lot depends on the money available. Around 1980, we had a contract to cap shafts on Bonsall Moor in Derbyshire. We capped hundreds of them - 72 in one field! However they were only small and done with concrete railway sleepers. Some of the bigger ones had Bison beams instead. None of these caps would survive a collapsed lining but overall the moor is a safer place.
In the early 90's, we did the Snailbeach shafts. They were different again being large, deep and well trampled by tourists. For that reason money was available and they got the full treatment.
Georges shaft for instance, was filled with tip tailings up to the rockhead. At that point we drilled dowel holes and cast a 3metre thick plug. Then filled again with selected tailings up to near the surface and another concrete slab that forms the bottom of the dummy shaft seen now about 2metres down. I would guess that that one shaft cost more than half of Bonsall Moor to treat.