patch
  • patch
  • 50.2% (Neutral)
  • Newbie Topic Starter
17 years ago
Back in the mid 1970's I was involved in some work on the Alva Silver mines. I believe they have since been worked. Can anyone tell me what the state of play is today.

The above work led to me co-editing a booklet, "Mines and Minerals of the Ochils" which was published by the Clackmannanshire Field Studies Society. I still have the orginal artwork and type. Can anyone give me a contact these days for the CFSS. Google search offers umpteen links and names, but nothing up-to-date with an email address?
Don't wait for a light to appear at the end of the tunnel, stride down there and light the damn thing yourself
tiger99
17 years ago
The only thing that has happened since is that the entrances were gated or fenced by the Woodlands Trust. I am sure there has been no other working.

I suspect that the CFSS or at least their publications have been absorbed into the Forth Naturalist and Historian. http://www.fnh.stir.ac.uk/ 

I think we have been waiting for a reprint of Mines and Minerals of the Ochils, Airthrey and Bridge of Allan for many years now, which suggests that CFSS may have disbanded. And yet http://www.communityplanningaberdeen.org.uk/nmsruntime/saveasdialog.asp?lID=2903&sID=364  this suggests that they had a grant for producing a publication as recently as last year.

So maybe they still exist, but are keeping a low profile. You could try asking the Clackmannanshire County Council in Alloa if they know, or if you are in the area, try asking at the library, which usually has copies of their publications for sale.



patch
  • patch
  • 50.2% (Neutral)
  • Newbie Topic Starter
17 years ago
Thanks for that Tiger. Often wondered what happened. Will call in at Alloa Library next time I'm in the "wee county"
Don't wait for a light to appear at the end of the tunnel, stride down there and light the damn thing yourself
rhychydwr
17 years ago
Jeffreys, Alan L 2007 is the key work:


Alva Silver Mine, NGR NS 88 97 Landranger 58 Silver Glen, Alva [NE of Stirling], Clackmannanshire
First worked in 1715, the Alva Silver Mine is the richest deposit of native silver ever found in Great Britain. Native silver occurs as dendritic crystal aggregates to several cm, associated with clinsafflorite and rammelsbergite in a dolomite-baryte-calcite gangue. Moreton, S 1996 The Alva Silver Mine, Silver Glen, Alva, Scotland. Mineralogical Record 27 (6) 405-414

Anon 1963 Alva Silver Mines. Alloa Advertiser 5 April 1963 8. Source Brown 1980

Anon ND Alva Silva Mines. Northern Notes & Queries or The Scottish Antiquary 1 (4) 53-55

Anon 2007 A Rich Vein. Broadleaf. The Magazine of the Woodland Trust (68) Spring. 13 silver mines in Wood Hill, Clackmannanshire. [Alva]

Beadman, D R, et al 2002 Design and construction of a tunnel above abandoned mine workings: the Roughcastle tunnel, Falkirk, Scotland. Mining Technology 111 (12) 99-105

Dickie, D M, and Forster, C W, Editors, assisted by Mrs E Lumsden, J Ritchie, A Roy and R Woodburn. 2nd ed 1974; reprint 1986 Mines and Minerals of the Ochils. Clackmannanshire Field Studies Society. 43, maps, illus. Airthrey Silver Mine, Alva Silver Mines, John Erskine’s Mine, Carnaughton Glen Mines, Blairlogies Mines, Burn of Sorrow Mine, Tillicoultry Mines, Daiglen Mine, Balquharn Mines, Jerah Mines, Myreton Calcite Workings.

Edie, William L, 1924 Precious metals of Scotland, prospecting and where found. Kirkcaldy. Fifeshire Advertiser 39. Brief mention of Alva silver 14-16. Source Brown 1980

Francis, E H et al 1970 The Geology of the Stirling District. Memoirs of the Geological Survey of Scotland. Chapter XIX Economic Geology 292-307. Detailed description of 24 mines with NGRs

Green and Todd 11

Harrison, John G, 2003 Heavy Metal Mines in the Ochils: Chronology and Context. Forth Naturalist and Historian 26 105-118. Bridge of Allan, Allan Water NS 787 983, Airthey Hill Mine NS 8152 9720, Aiirthrey Silver Mine NS 8152 9720, Blairlogie Trials, Jerah Mine NS 8323 9949 & NS 8300 9982, Balquharn Burn Trials NS 8653 9782 the site of Earl of Stirling’s mines c 1607, also worked in mid 18th century. Carnaughton Glen Silver Mine NS 8781 9754, Alva Silver mine, Tillicoultry NS 9234 9812, Kirk NS 9124 9780 and Daiglen Burns NS 9106 9834, Dollar Burn NN 9455 0021, Pendreich NS 8065 9922, Western bank of Allan Water NS 787 983. All Landranger 57

Jeffreys, Alan L 2007 The Alva Silver Mines. Ser 4 GSG 3 (2) 18-25, 8 B&W photos, 2 colour photos opp 26, location map, surveys. The definitive work on the currently accessible workings.

M&M (10) IV

MacOwan, Rennie 2007 Scots Magazine July 167 (1) 80. Heading for the Hills / The saga of the Silver Glen. A review of Moreton 2007 ibid.

Moreton, S 1996 The Alva Silver Mine, Silver Glen, Alva, Scotland. Mineralogical Record 27 (6) 405-414

Moreton, Stephen 2007 Bonanzas and Jacobites / The Story of the Silver Glen. 94 pp, many photos, some in colour. Edinburgh, National Museums Scotland. A detailed history of the Alva Silver mines from 1715 to date, including the discovery of cobalt in 1758. Thoroughly referenced, chapter by chapter, with additional notes and background information accompanying the references. List of minerals found and descriptions of the mines still open, includes a Radon warning.

Palmer, William T, 1947 The Verge of the Scottish Highlands. Robert Hale Ltd, London 148-149 “Ochil Silver. The silver yield of the Alva mines two centuries ago was startling. The Silver Glen between Middle and Wood hills made £4,000 a week for Sir John Erskine. The Government’s attention was drawn to the valuable veins of ore, two of which were particularly rich and produced in a few week 134 ounces of the richest silver, as assayed and tested by no less a personage than Sir Isaac Newton, then Master of the Mint. In 1715 Sir John entered a perilous adventure to bring back the Stuarts. He left his wife in charge of the mines and of forty tons of silver ore buried in the grounds of Alva House. The rising failed and Sir John was outlawed. To buy back the Government’s favour he sent information about his silver ore, and in the winter of 1716-7, a Mint expert reported that:

“I found it (the ore) of an extraordinary nature, such as to my knowledge few or none like have ever seen in Europe. It consists of sulphur, arsenic, iron, some lead and good silver. Of all these the silver is only to be regarded, for the other minerals and metals contained in the ore are of little value, and not worth the charge to separate and keep them”.

“The treasure-trove is said to have produced £40,000 to £50,000, but Sir John did not prosper, the output diminished, and the mines soon came to an end.”

Proctor, John and Bacon, Margaret E 1979 The plants and soils of two mineral workings in the Ochil Hills. Forth Naturalist and Historian 3 71-77, 2 figs.

Scott, Douglas M, May 1997 Mining in the Ochils. Scots Mag 146 (5) 488-492 Alva Silver Mine, Bridge of Allan, Airthrey Silver Mine, Blairlogie Copper Mines, Burn of Sorrow Mine, Mill Glen Trial, Daiglen Mine, Kirk Glen Trial, Balquharn Mine, Carnaughton Silver Mine.



Cutting coal in my spare time.
patch
  • patch
  • 50.2% (Neutral)
  • Newbie Topic Starter
17 years ago
Rhychydwr
What more could I possibly ask for!

Many thanks

Don't wait for a light to appear at the end of the tunnel, stride down there and light the damn thing yourself

Disclaimer: Mine exploring can be quite dangerous, but then again it can be alright, it all depends on the weather. Please read the proper disclaimer.
© 2005 to 2023 AditNow.co.uk

Dedicated to the memory of Freda Lowe, who believed this was worth saving...