dwarrowdelf
8 years ago
On reading the various reports on the Chile Mine rescue of 2010, which occurred at the San Jose copper and gold mine near Copiapo in the Atacama desert of Northern Chile, I was struck by the lack of any reference at all to radon emissions, both in the daily working of the mine, or in reference to the condition or monitoring of the trapped miners. Mention of radon seems to be conspicuously absent from all the accounts I have read online, in books, or various newspaper reports. The published material in particular, appears to be detailed in so many ways, I would have thought some mention of this would have been made at some point, if only to pin point its lack of monitoring, or otherwise, in the working mine or its absence in the workings, - if it was indeed absent.

I have however failed to locate a very detailed geological description of this particular mine and it would be great to see one – even the easily available plans/diagrams of the main workings are woefully inadequate – not a big surprise there, by the way!

The rock which composes the essential structure of the mountain containing the San Jose mine is described as granite in many of the reports and in at least one detailed publication, as diorite – an intrusive igneous rock - often simply described as granite. One other source described the tough rock the drillers had to battle against as a “volcanic
conglomerate with very high silica content”

Would be surprised if the entire hardstone content of the mountain was exclusively one material - but I suppose it can happen.

On the subject of rock identification, I have repeatedly had the various samples of igneous rocks I’ve picked up around Cwmorthin, described to me as “granite” when I'm fairly certain most were not !

(Have the same problem with native American hardstone artefacts – but that's a different story)
'I wonder how many breakfasts, and other meals we have missed inside that nasty clockless, timeless hole?'

'The Hobbit'
J R R Tolkien.
crickleymal
8 years ago
I doubt whether there's enough H&S in the country to be concerned with Radon.
Malc.
Rusted and ropey, Dog eared old copy
Vintage and classic or just plain Jurassic
All words to describe me.
dwarrowdelf
8 years ago
Even when expertise came in from abroad, there was still no mention of the possibility or otherwise of radon,at least in the sources I found. but to be honest, not a huge amount on the detailed geology was made available either. If I remember rightly, many popular sources stated that the miners were buried under "granite" and left it at that,except for the small number of reports which mentioned diorite, which, since this isn't such a "household" word so to speak, must perhaps be a better term for what much of the rock actually was.

'I wonder how many breakfasts, and other meals we have missed inside that nasty clockless, timeless hole?'

'The Hobbit'
J R R Tolkien.
J25GTi
  • J25GTi
  • 50.2% (Neutral)
  • Newbie
8 years ago
"dwarrowdelf" wrote:

Even when expertise came in from abroad, there was still no mention of the possibility or otherwise of radon,at least in the sources I found. but to be honest, not a huge amount on the detailed geology was made available either. If I remember rightly, many popular sources stated that the miners were buried under "granite" and left it at that,except for the small number of reports which mentioned diorite, which, since this isn't such a "household" word so to speak, must perhaps be a better term for what much of the rock actually was.



Why are you worried about it?

I doubt the levels were anything to worry about for the time they were down there. I have been down "hot: mines and deal with radon alot at work. The exposure they have had would be minimal...

The risk was the half a million tonnes of rock that came crashing down. 😮
dwarrowdelf
8 years ago
Just a point of academic interest really. I go underground whenever i have the chance, never really worried about radon personally. Hanging death and "house of card" slabs have been much more of a concern 😞
'I wonder how many breakfasts, and other meals we have missed inside that nasty clockless, timeless hole?'

'The Hobbit'
J R R Tolkien.
J25GTi
  • J25GTi
  • 50.2% (Neutral)
  • Newbie
8 years ago
"dwarrowdelf" wrote:

Just a point of academic interest really. I go underground whenever i have the chance, never really worried about radon personally. Hanging death and "house of card" slabs have been much more of a concern :(



Exactly that. I doubt radon really even figured on their risk assessment!

Disclaimer: Mine exploring can be quite dangerous, but then again it can be alright, it all depends on the weather. Please read the proper disclaimer.
© 2005 to 2023 AditNow.co.uk

Dedicated to the memory of Freda Lowe, who believed this was worth saving...