Absolutely agree Nick, fins are a mud trap and become next to useless when muddy. The answer is probably to pick the correct LED (as I have found out the XML is not necessarily the best choice despite its claim for efficiency!), optics and an efficient driver.
I will not argue with you Roy regarding feedback. The very fact it increases efficiency and hence battery life is IMO a justifiable reason to employ the system, especially in squalid caves, as long, as has been stated you are able to override and work off manual modes, as appears can be done with both my own and Newstuff's own lamp.
This is making me more determined to get my lamp out there a bit more for other's to try, needs a lot of work to take it beyond a prototype though!