In all fairness the water in the dam was close to potable quality, it's the suspended solids comprising quartz, feldspar and clays with traces of sulphides that are the issue. Doubtless we will see the yoghurt weavers and sundry tree huggers complaining on the net without thinking that their computers need copper, gold, rare earth's, lithium and nickel / cadmium to even exist. Perhaps they think metals are grown?
The Mt Polley dam failure has yet to be explained and the company had a very good environmental record to date. No matter how good the engineering sometimes things fail and this does seem to be one of those cases. However unlike the Aznalcollar dam failure in Spain some years ago the tails from Mt Polly are relatively environmentally benign and the ecosystem will recover quite quickly.
Not being an apologist or a company spokesman just trying to look at this accident with a degree of common sense.