Ahaaa, back on a working computer.
My cynicism was borne out of my time working alongside metallurgists and at the lab. Not putting too fine a point on it, bags of all sorts would come in, as well as half-cores. People would inspect the stuff like mineral collectors, looking at the material, it would go through a variety of crushers, screens, tables, froth and heavy liquids, etc, etc. The results would come back from the lab and it would be possible to piece together the order of size of things and how significant they are.
I remember reading another report from the 60s about "one of the Cornish projects (not that one, or that one) and the grades were outstanding. Really outstanding. It was almost a no-brainer.
What saddens me is that Cornwall has totally lost it. You read about diamond drilling rigs appearing all around Cornwall in the 60s, people clearing shafts and then onto people actually having a go at opening the mine. I read an article about Wheal Jane in 73 and how it was the 2nd largest underground tin mine in the world. You read the first paragraph of Wheal Concord (the book) and it's inspiring stuff. They went out, opened some shafts up, did a load of drilling and actually did something. They produced stuff out of a hole!
Prices have gone up and up and up and there are no drilling rigs (doing anything apart form heat/water bore holes, or doing mining investigations). There are no headgears and everything is pretty much grinding to a halt.
I was right there sorting through a load of phosphate samples for screening and the TV were interviewing "this chap" about "his project". Shortly afterwards, there was hell up. Utter hell up. The lentilists were wetting the bed over the through of what this chap was proposing. They didn't read the report, they didn't understand anything about what was proposed, all they thought was some greedy capitalist was going to tear up the environment and all the cuddly bunnies and fishy-wishies were going to snuff it. There are millions of pounds waiting to be harvested and it gets killed by some nonsense.
I also have a chum who is "something to do with" the other project. There is talk of them "never being allowed to do anything, because of 101 environmental reasons". Then you hear about Crofty never being allowed to pump and it's shameful.
I had a chat to the metallurgists/mining geologists about this and the likely direction of mining/milling tech is towards bigger machines digging out bigger amounts of low grade stuff and automated everything and improved milling technology being the likely direction. It seems that HSE with their apparent stuff regarding airleg/hand drilling is the next nail in the coffin.
My comment about employment was due to ratio of diggers to men and the virtual automation of the mill.
I've read the Jack Trounson books and I had total faith in his belief in the Cornish deposits and the men who could work them. It was there in the 60's and later.
It seems that recent legislation for the (over) protection of everyone has meant that no-one in their right mind would bother. There are the excited mutterings of people saying "When hermerdon has opened up, it'll be the catalyst, you'll have all sorts of people opening allsorts". I don't think it will.
I was looking for information of Wheal Squire (carharrack) on the internet and bizarrely, I bumped into the chap from Cornwall Mining Services and his mad crew of swashbuckling, speculating pirates who were looking at tin in Outer Wood. I wondered what those laddered shafts and stagings were from...they were clearly different to Wheal Jane's techniques.
Hemerdon is going to be a bloody big hole, Treliver might get to be a not-so-big hole, if it has blessing from god with planning and the eco-people. If crofty breaks another rock, I will eat my own beard and marine minerals are more of a non-starter than an 80's skoda.
I am aware of 2 separate groups of people (apart from the Duchy and those sat on Redmoor) who are very very keen to establish who owns what mineral rights and increasing their portfolios. It certainly looks to me like they are aiming on speculating, rather than actually doing any mining. It all looks a bit like people hoping someone will come along and offer them millions and millions for their little collection of rights and flooded holes.
It's a shame, you look at the subject matter of geology, mineralogy, chemistry as well as engineering and firsts and Cornwall is there, it was a nation apart, hard working wirey men with a unique culture making firsts, being instrumental in humanity's progress, the whole topic is littered with the most incredible historical record and to participate in it is to truly belong. It's a part of the Cornish identity and it's a part of the reason miners are like a brotherhood.
I've met a fair few chaps who would like their jobs back and many more with a fond regard for past times, when people gained worth by something other than tourism. They'd like to see locals have some pride and identity, rather than grovelling at the bottom of the food chain for emmets pennies. I've worked with the drillers who would like to get back coring, rather than doing bloody heat pump holes.
Behind the scenes, there are things going on and Hemerdon appears to be different, in that it has permission to actually go ahead, unlike others in our glorious tourist museum of Kernow. (Wind your windows up through hayle)